Short or useless comments. (3231 views, 20 replies)
top expert
admin
admin
senior guru
I disagree slightly with this because..seeing comments stating whether a movie is good or not or just ok gives you an idea if the movie is worth while watching. <br> <br> Comments are not really a place for reviews on the movie there is a seperate tab for reviews if people would like to make one. <br> <br> I think saying too much about a movie spoils it for the others who have not yet viewed it (yes there is the spoiler option but most people do not use it).
@ATouchOfClass We have a movie rating for it (yellow stars) Imho no need to say "I liked this movie 4/5". <br> <br> Why did you like the movie - that IS important imho. This is my position :)
@Dr.Evil I totally get that and agree that this is what a comment should contain also. <br> <br> You cannot rely fully on the movie rating as people have different tastes. <br> <br> There have been a few movies I have watched that I thought were under-rated. <br> <br> I think maybe I didn't explain what I meant properly and it has come across wrong. <br> <br> I think it is a good idea to want more than this is a good movie ect.. I just felt that this might encourage people to babble on a little about other things to just make the comment longer. <br> <br> Not that I think this change is a bad idea.
top expert
I agree with ATOUCHOFCLASS, and to be honest I usually just disregard the star ratings that are there, if I see enough "it was okay 2/5" I know well enough it wont be worth my time, plus seeing a whole column as to why someone else thought it was great or bad, doesn't spark my interest either. I don't want to read a whole paragraph on what another person thought about the movie. A Few opinions is okay, going into detail gets redundant and boring.
admin
@Dr.Evil It appears to be a TD troll or a TD and a few of their buddies/extra accounts. <br> They're everywhere on the internet and even sites like Yahoo and Yahoo!Answers has mindless users who take enjoyment out of giving TD to nearly every comment.
@Dr.Evil Yea I have noticed this is happening a lot on my comments lately.. someone is defo taking the p*** lol...
top expert
yey most thumbs down on this page wooo
its prob one of the losers who blocked me for no reason lol
top expert
Geesh!! This is no longer a forum! It's more like a place for INTERNET BULLIES to come and pick on and bash other members. Now go ahead let me have it...
Similar forum topics
- Cannot Downvote or Report Comments (6 years ago)
- Rhetoric Warning Sign to reduce Stupid Argument (2 years ago)
- What the hell is THIS? (6 years ago)
- ToS Explanatory Note (2 years ago)
- Book Nook... What are your favorite books...or short stories? (6 years ago)
- Now comments are reviews! (5 years ago)
- What's up with not been able to edit or delet your reviews? (3 years ago)
- Changing mistaken thumbs down/thumbs up on comments (8 years ago)
- "Comments" inquiry (6 years ago)
admin
Comments like: 4/5, this movie is ok, good movie etc... or useless comments will be removed. <br> <br> Why? Please think about other users that read your comments. Add value to your comments. Tell them why did you like a movie, your feelings, etc. <br> <br> Thank you
<br>
<br>